307: Casey Apple Pencil

Joy-Con Issues

The Nintendo Switch's Joy-Con controllers spark a lively debate among the hosts. John Siracusa criticizes their ergonomic design, noting that while they are versatile, they are not comfortable for prolonged use, especially in horizontal mode 1. Casey Liss agrees, highlighting the physical discomfort caused by the bulges when used in this mode 1. Marco Arment adds his disdain for the Joy-Cons, preferring a larger, more comfortable controller 2. Despite their shortcomings, the Joy-Cons' adaptability is acknowledged, but they fall short in terms of comfort and usability for adult hands 3.

I find using the Joy Con in a D pad mode or in a, like, horizontal mode to be basically painful.

--- John Siracusa

The consensus is that while the Joy-Cons are innovative, they are not ideal for serious gaming sessions.

   

Pro Controller

The Pro Controller for the Nintendo Switch receives a more favorable review. John Siracusa appreciates its design, noting that it addresses many of the ergonomic issues present in the Joy-Cons 4. He describes it as a significant improvement, offering a more traditional gaming experience with better button placement and comfort 4. Marco Arment concurs, praising its USB-C charging and overall feel, though he wishes for a power switch to prevent accidental activation 5. The Pro Controller is seen as a necessary accessory for those seeking a more comfortable and responsive gaming experience on the Switch.

The Pro Controller is not the best controller ever made, but it addresses the controller ness of the switch.

--- John Siracusa

Overall, the Pro Controller is recommended for enhancing the Switch's usability and comfort.