620: Mostly Cookies

Frustrations

The iOS 18 Photos app has sparked significant frustration among users due to its unfamiliar interface and usability issues. John Siracusa highlights the app's resistance to user input, particularly the difficulty in dismissing the bottom white section, which requires multiple swipes 1. This design choice deviates from common iPhone interface paradigms, leading to user confusion and dissatisfaction. Siracusa notes, "It's weird that the app, like, resists you, hiding that bottom part. Like, you push down, it doesn't go away. You have to push down a second time."

It's weird that the app, like, resists you, hiding that bottom part. Like, you push down, it doesn't go away. You have to push down a second time.

--- John Siracusa

This resistance is emblematic of broader issues with the app's redesign, which many users find counterintuitive and frustrating 2.

   

Feedback

Feedback on the iOS 18 Photos app has been overwhelmingly negative, with many users expressing dissatisfaction with the changes. Marco Arment describes himself as a light user, noting that the new features often get in the way rather than enhance the experience 3. Casey Liss shares a similar sentiment, acknowledging the backlash from regular users who find the app's redesign cumbersome 4. Siracusa adds, "The fact that regular people are saying anything about iOS 18 is probably bad for Apple because what Apple wants is just like, oh, my iPhone got better."

The fact that regular people are saying anything about iOS 18 is probably bad for Apple because what Apple wants is just like, oh, my iPhone got better.

--- John Siracusa

This sentiment underscores the disconnect between Apple's intentions and user expectations, highlighting the challenges of balancing innovation with usability.

   

Interface Changes

The user interface changes in iOS 18's Photos app have significantly impacted usability, with many users struggling to adapt. Siracusa points out the difficulty in navigating the app, particularly with the new pinned collections and the persistent white bottom section 5. He suggests that the app's design choices, such as the non-intuitive toolbar, have made it harder for users to find their photos efficiently. Siracusa remarks, "I would love it if that toolbar is customizable."

I would love it if that toolbar is customizable.

--- John Siracusa

This desire for customization reflects a broader need for user-friendly design that accommodates diverse user preferences and workflows 6.