Fixing the messy voluntary carbon market | Catalyst with Shayle Kann

Methodologies

Emerging methodologies in carbon removal are reshaping the market landscape by introducing modular protocols. Ryan Orbuch explains that these protocols are developed in partnership with suppliers and experts, allowing for flexibility and updates as scientific understanding evolves 1. This modular approach contrasts with traditional registries that have numerous overlapping methodologies, making it difficult to standardize processes. Orbuch emphasizes the importance of creating a system that is both contractable and adaptable to scientific changes, ensuring consistency in carbon credit delivery 2.

The supplier needs the instruction set to deliver against, and the value for this needs to be in this range for that to count.

--- Ryan Orbuch

These new methodologies aim to provide a clear framework for suppliers to follow, ultimately leading to more reliable carbon removal outcomes.

   

Uncertainty

Scientific uncertainty poses significant challenges in the carbon removal sector, particularly in measurement and verification. Shayle Kann notes that while these methods are often cheaper than engineered solutions, they come with complex measurement challenges, especially in areas like oceans and soils 3. Orbuch highlights the need for a dynamic feedback loop that adapts to evolving scientific knowledge, ensuring that carbon removal efforts are effective and credible 4.

We're learning new stuff about carbon removal and even just forest science all the time.

--- Ryan Orbuch

This approach requires a shift from an accounting-first to a science-first mindset, allowing for adjustments as new information becomes available.