Published Jun 6, 2022

Pitchfork: Ryan Schreiber

Explore the meteoric rise of Pitchfork from a humble webpage to a powerhouse music publication through the lens of its founder, Ryan Schreiber, as he navigates pivotal moments like the impactful 'Kid A' review, the creation of the Pitchfork Music Festival, and the complexities of joining Condé Nast.
Episode Highlights
How I Built This logo

Popular Clips

Episode Highlights

  • Webpage Start

    Ryan Schreiber's journey began in 1994 when he was introduced to the Internet while working at a record store. Inspired by the burgeoning online world, he learned basic web design skills and launched a simple website called Turntable, which featured interviews with local bands like Low 1. Schreiber's passion for indie music and his commitment to daily updates set his site apart, eventually evolving into Pitchfork, a platform that gained traction due to its unique content and lack of competition 2.

    I started writing two reviews a day after a while. At that point, it was really uncommon for websites to be updated daily.

    ---

    His dedication to providing fresh content helped establish Pitchfork as a go-to source for indie music reviews.

       

    Early Struggles

    Building Pitchfork into a successful business was fraught with challenges, including financial struggles and the need for constant innovation. Schreiber faced difficulties in securing advertisers and sustaining himself financially, which led him to temporarily retreat to a cabin in Minnesota to regroup 3. Despite these setbacks, his determination to make Pitchfork a viable business never wavered.

    I couldn't make my rent because even though I gave myself no alternative but to turn Pitchfork into a successful business, I couldn't do it that quickly.

    ---

    By focusing on ad sales and building a network of advertisers, he eventually returned to Chicago with renewed vigor and a clearer business strategy 4 5.

       

    Rebranding

    The transition from Turntable to Pitchfork marked a significant rebranding moment for Schreiber. After receiving a cease and desist letter from a company with a similar name, he was inspired by a scene in the movie Scarface to rename his site Pitchfork, reflecting a sharper, more aggressive editorial style 6. This new identity aligned with his vision of setting a high bar for music reviews and resonated with his audience.

    I really wanted Pitchfork to be more aggressive in its review style, to be harder on music and, I don't know, have a higher bar.

    ---

    The rebranding helped solidify Pitchfork's reputation as a bold and influential voice in the music industry.

Related Episodes