Published September 2023 on Spotfiy

892: Tim Urban | What's Our Problem (And How Do We Solve It)?

1. Introduction

Tim Urban joins the show to discuss the reasons behind political polarization and tribalism, emphasizing the importance of intellectual honesty in our conversations. This insightful conversation applies to anyone living in a country with a government.+

2. Technology's Impact

Technology's Role:Explore the impact of technology on our society and the potential for destruction, as discussed in Tim Urban's book. Discover the surprising reaction of his 97-year-old grandmother to his work.+
The Dark Valley:Tim Urban discusses the pattern of unintended consequences and harm that often follows the introduction of new media technologies, using examples such as the printing press and cable TV. He explores the cycles of euphoria, chaos, and eventual integration that occur, highlighting the importance of managing and regulating these technologies to avoid negative outcomes.+
Media Chaos:Tim Urban discusses the evolution of media, from the Fairness Doctrine to the rise of tribal media and social media, highlighting the shift towards valuing clicks over accuracy and the impact on journalism and elections.+

3. Human History Unveiled

The Book of Human History:Tim Urban uses a book analogy to put the span of human history into perspective. With humanity's existence of 250,000 years, he explains that 95% of that time was spent as hunter gatherers. Only in the last 5% have significant advancements, like agriculture and writing, occurred.+
The Anomaly of Page 1000:Tim Urban discusses how our current era is a unique anomaly in human history, with rapid advancements in technology and knowledge acquisition. He compares our time to the last few pages of a book, highlighting the significant shifts that have occurred in the past 250 years. From the Industrial Revolution to the rise of fossil fuels, Urban emphasizes the excitement and potential fear of living in such a transformative period.+

4. The Cycle of Wisdom

The Cycle of Wisdom:Tim Urban and Jordan discuss the cyclical nature of wisdom throughout history and how societies often forget the lessons of the past, leading to potential trouble in the future. They explore the importance of remembering history and not taking societal norms for granted, highlighting the need for wisdom to be upheld across generations.+
High Rung, Low Rung:Tim Urban discusses the importance of high rung thinking, where one is open to truth and not attached to their ideas, versus low rung thinking, where one's identity becomes tied to their beliefs. He explores how this mindset affects our interactions with others and our ability to create a better future.+

5. Seeking Truth, Tribal Mindset

Seeking Truth, Tribal Mindset:Tim Urban explores the relationship between truth seeking and a tribal mindset, highlighting the dangers of attachment to ideas and the dehumanization of those who disagree. He emphasizes the importance of persuasion over coercion and the potential for a more unified and cooperative society.+
The Danger of Echo Chambers:Tim Urban discusses the dangers of conformity and the echo chamber mentality in society, drawing parallels to the Khmer Rouge and extremist ideologies. He highlights the financial incentives behind reinforcing tribalistic ideas and the harm it causes to individuals and society as a whole.+

6. The Dangers of Tribal Media

The Truth About Tribal Media:Tim Urban and Jordan Harbinger discuss the dangers of consuming tribal media, comparing it to eating junk food for the brain. They explore how tribal media can lead to a false sense of righteousness and the importance of seeking truth and being open to changing our opinions.+
Protecting Ideas, Seeking Truth:Tim Urban discusses the mindset of protecting ideas versus seeking truth, emphasizing the importance of being open to criticism and changing one's mind. He highlights the difference in behavior between those who protect their ideas and those who are focused on improving them.+
The Tribal Mindset:Tim Urban and Jordan Harbinger discuss the dangers of tribalism and the importance of independent thinking in a world dominated by echo chambers. They explore how tribalism limits our knowledge and hinders intellectual growth, while emphasizing the need for humility and seeking out dissenting opinions.+

7. The Power of Dissent

Tim Urban discusses the importance of embracing dissent and challenging the status quo throughout history, drawing examples from ancient Greece and Galileo's house arrest. He highlights how the search for truth and independent thinking can lead to progress and innovation, even in the face of opposition.+

8. Sponsors

Enhancing Sleep:Discover how Momentous sleep pack can help you fall asleep faster, stay asleep longer, and wake up feeling rejuvenated with its scientifically backed formulation of high-quality minerals and vitamins.+
Strategic Hiring Tips:Learn about the most effective way to find quality candidates for your company's roles and how ZipRecruiter can supercharge your recruitment process.+

9. Challenging Binary Thinking

Challenging Binary Thinking:Tim Urban discusses the dangers of binary thinking and the use of straw man arguments in shaping public opinion. He explains how these tactics can weaken our ability to consider nuanced perspectives and how they are often employed in cable news shows.+
The Echo Chamber Effect:Tim Urban discusses the dangers of echo chambers in politics, highlighting how they limit exposure to opposing viewpoints and lead to a distorted understanding of issues. He emphasizes the importance of doing thorough research and seeking out nuanced perspectives to combat this phenomenon.+
The Inoculation Effect:Tim Urban discusses the inoculation effect, using gun control and climate change as examples. He explains how repeatedly hearing weak arguments in echo chambers can make individuals immune to considering opposing viewpoints.+

10. Challenging Beliefs

Immunity to Changing Minds:Tim Urban and Jordan Harbinger discuss the dangers of becoming immune to changing our minds due to media influence and tribalism. They explore how our beliefs can become rigid and how this hinders progress and problem-solving.+
The Problem with Conspiracy Theories:Jordan and Tim discuss the dangers of believing in conspiracy theories, emphasizing the importance of skepticism and critical thinking. They highlight that while some conspiracy theories may be true, most are not, and sensationalizing every issue can lead to misinformation and fearmongering.+

11. Media Sensationalism

Media Sensationalism:Tim Urban discusses the dangers of sensationalized media and the impact it has on our ability to discern real threats. He emphasizes the importance of taking real threats seriously, such as COVID, amidst a sea of conspiracy theories and media hype cycles.+
The YouTube Reality Show:Tim Urban discusses how YouTube serves up bombastic political content and creates a political reality show, while ignoring nuanced politicians like Derek Kilmer. He also explores the potential for AI to provide balanced news and counterpoints to articles.+

12. The Power of Debate

Tim Urban discusses the value of debates in shaping opinions and challenging biases. He explores the idea of using AI to create engaging debates between experts with different viewpoints.+

13. Real Debates, Tribalism

Jordan and Tim discuss the lack of real debates and the impact of tribalism on society, highlighting how the focus on blasting agendas to the already receptive audience hinders progress and fuels the tribal war. They emphasize the need for nuanced discussions and compromise to push the country forward.+

14. Sponsors

Breaking Negative Thought Cycles:Discover how to break free from negative thought cycles and improve your mental health with online therapy from BetterHelp.+
Streamline Your Business:Discover how NetSuite can revolutionize your business operations and boost efficiency with its tailored solution, used by over 36,000 businesses. Download their KPI checklist for free at Title: Supporting Sponsors Topics: Sponsorship, Support Summary: Learn how to support the show by checking out the amazing sponsors and deals on the website. Visit to find out more.+

15. The Writing Process

Tim Urban shares his writing process, from soaking in ideas to creating a clever outline, all with the goal of efficiently conveying information and making it fun for readers.+

16. Writing Process Insights

Writing Process Insights:Tim Urban shares his insights on the writing process, emphasizing the importance of a concise outline and conducting research as you go. He also discusses the challenge of retaining fresh insights over time and the dance between research, outlining, writing, and revising. Jordan Harbinger praises Tim's conversational writing style and acknowledges the complexity behind it.+
Finding Your Writing Zone:Tim Urban shares his journey of finding his writing zone through blogging and how it allowed him to explore and experiment creatively without the pressure of being a professional writer. He also discusses the importance of maintaining that tone and how external reminders can help bring back the fun and originality in writing.+

17. Finding Freshness in Creativity

Finding Creativity in Freshness:Tim Urban discusses how staying in a creative zone can lead to fresh and funny moments in public speaking, but also the challenge of replicating that success. Jordan Harbinger explores the concept of concept creep and how definitions have evolved, using the example of the word "racism."+
The Power of Words:Tim Urban discusses the impact of using powerful words like racism and trauma too frequently, leading to a dilution of their meaning. He explores how this affects society and the danger of labeling simple disagreements as acts of violence.+

18. Political Language Unpacked

Political Language and Concept Creep:Tim Urban and Jordan Harbinger discuss the intense language used in American politics, such as calling the January 6 protest an insurrection. They also explore the concept creep phenomenon, where words like "groomer" and "transphobe" have expanded in meaning, leading to potential misunderstandings and abuse.+
Concept Creep:Tim and Jordan discuss the concept of concept creep, where the definitions of words like racism and oppression expand to include lesser offenses. They explore the positive and negative implications of this phenomenon, highlighting the importance of paying attention to subtle forms of bias while acknowledging the potential for the definition to expand infinitely.+

19. Understanding Microaggressions

Microaggressions and Impact:Jordan and Tim discuss the concept of microaggressions and the importance of understanding their impact, regardless of intent. They delve into the dangers of a victimhood mindset and the consequences of censorship in academia, shedding light on the need for open dialogue and thorough understanding.+
Challenging Campus Orthodoxy:Tim Urban discusses the dangers of enforcing orthodoxy on college campuses and the impact it has on academic freedom and intellectual growth. He highlights the importance of open dialogue and the potential consequences of stifling controversial ideas.+

20. Social Justice and Echo Chambers

Tim Urban discusses the modern movement of social justice and its deviation from traditional liberal values. He explores the dangers of echo chambers and the need for open-mindedness in society. Jordan Harbinger emphasizes the importance of creating an idea lab rather than an echo chamber, highlighting the negative impact of distrust in institutions.+

21. The Cancel Culture Nightmare

Jordan discusses the toxic nature of cancel culture and the impact it has on individuals, particularly podcasters. He shares his strategy of opting out of social media to protect his reputation and emphasizes the importance of not giving negativity any attention. He also explores the unhealthy societal pressure to apologize even when one has done nothing wrong.+

22. Outro

Discover highlights and takeaways from previous episodes in The Jordan Harbinger Show newsletter. Plus, learn valuable networking skills with the six-minute networking course on the website.+