176 - Christianity and Polyamory

Sin's Complexity

Austin Adkinson and J.D. Mechelke explore the nuanced understanding of sin within Christianity, emphasizing that sin is not merely an ethical failing but a complex theological concept. Austin argues that sexual orientation should not be seen as inherently sinful, but rather how one engages with it matters 1. He stresses the importance of living according to the loving example set by Jesus, rather than strictly adhering to the letter of the law 1. J.D. introduces his project on creating a "kinky doctrine of sin," which examines Christian symbols within the context of BDSM communities 2.

Sin does not equal ethics in the Bible. Sin is something else.

--- J.D. Mechelke

This perspective challenges traditional views and encourages a broader interpretation of religious texts.

   

Sin vs Ethics

The discussion shifts to the distinction between sin and ethics in Christian theology, particularly in relation to polyamory. Austin highlights that many churches are re-evaluating their values as they encounter diverse family structures within their congregations 3. He notes that ancient religious laws often do not directly apply to modern contexts, and many prohibitions are understood to be overridden by the grace of Christ 3. J.D. adds that historical views on sexuality, such as virginity, were economically driven rather than ethically 4.

You can't lift an ancient concept and shove it into the modern era.

--- Austin Adkinson

This conversation underscores the need for contemporary interpretations of religious teachings.