Is Toby the Scranton Strangler? With Paul Lieberstein

Theory Origins

The Scranton Strangler theory began as a background joke in the series, evolving into a popular storyline. Angela Kinsey and Jenna Fischer discuss how the character became a recurring theme, with Toby Flenderson's obsession with the case adding to the intrigue 1. Paul Lieberstein, who plays Toby, shares that the idea may have originated from him, though it was initially intended as a one-off joke 2. The writers' room frequently pitched storylines involving the Strangler, reflecting its popularity among fans and creators alike 1.

When conceived, this was simply a newspaper joke.

--- Jenna Fischer

The theory's development showcases the collaborative nature of the show's writing process and its ability to turn a simple gag into a fan-favorite mystery.

   

Toby's Dark Side

Angela presents a compelling case for Toby being the Scranton Strangler, citing his personal struggles and mysterious behavior. She argues that Toby's traumatic experiences, such as his divorce and unrequited love for Pam, contribute to a profile fitting a serial killer 3. His fascination with crime and ability to compartmentalize emotions are highlighted as potential indicators of a darker side 4. Angela suggests that Toby's knowledge of framing someone for murder, as seen in his mystery novels, further implicates him in the Strangler's crimes 3.

Toby is the Scranton Strangler. Don't doubt it, because if you do, he will have fooled you too.

--- Angela Kinsey

These arguments paint a picture of Toby as a complex character, capable of hiding sinister motives beneath his mild-mannered exterior.

   

Alternate Suspects

Jenna counters Angela's claims by presenting alternate suspects and questioning the evidence against Toby. She highlights the lack of concrete evidence linking Toby to the murders and points out that other characters, like Creed and Gabe, exhibit more suspicious behavior 5. Jenna argues that Toby's empathetic nature contradicts the profile of a serial killer, and his absence during key events is circumstantial at best 6. Additionally, fan theories suggest other potential suspects, such as Robert California and Mose, who display traits more aligned with criminal behavior 7.

There is simply no concrete evidence linking Toby to these murders.

--- Jenna Fischer

These points challenge the notion of Toby as the Strangler, opening the door for further speculation and debate.