Published Jan 10, 2025
We ask again: Is AI a science?
Thomas Gilbert and Nathan Lambert delve into the nature of AI, questioning its status as a scientific discipline versus an engineering paradigm, while exploring the potential for AI to drive paradigm shifts akin to historical scientific revolutions, amidst the pressures of capitalism.

Topics covered
Popular Clips
Questions from this episode
- Asked by 181 people
- Asked by 146 people
- Asked by 140 people
- Asked by 130 people
- Asked by 129 people
- Asked by 127 people
- Asked by 126 people
- Asked by 117 people
- Asked by 114 people
- Asked by 100 people
- Asked by 94 people
- Asked by 76 people
- Asked by 69 people
Episode Highlights
Related Episodes


AI is literally the culture war, figuratively speaking
Answers 383 questions

Alchemy, Oppenheimer, and the quest for AGI
Answers 383 questions

Three pillars of AI power
Answers 383 questions

AI, feedback, and population public health
Answers 383 questions

AI in public: education, roads, and institutions
Answers 383 questions

Avoiding the AI burnout
Answers 383 questions

Into the AI Trough of Disillusionment
Answers 383 questions

Teaser: Welcome to The Retort
Answers 383 questions

Apple sends a memo to the AGI faithful
Answers 383 questions

The Retort's biggest AI stories of 2024
Answers 383 questions

We believe in the metaverse
Answers 383 questions

As Above, So Below: Alchemy, AI Safety, and RLHF
Answers 383 questions

The Nobel Albatross
Answers 383 questions

What we are getting wrong about AI regulation
Answers 383 questions

Q* and OpenAI's Strange Loop: We Pecan't Even
Answers 383 questions
