Is AI being neglected?


Dwarkesh Patel, along with several guests, has discussed the concerns around AI potentially being neglected. Here are some perspectives shared:

  1. Dominic Cummings emphasized the lack of focus and urgency regarding AI, especially in political and intelligence circles. He noted that even as late as 2019-2020, there was little attention paid to the strategic importance of AI, which he tried to highlight by wearing an OpenAI T-shirt to meetings. Cummings mentioned that if intelligence agencies like GCHQ or NSA were directed to focus on AI advancements, such as those in China, substantial valuable information could be gathered. However, he pointed out that the disinterest and risk aversion within political and intelligence systems hindered such efforts 1 .

  2. Holden Karnofsky suggested that AI is significantly underappreciated when considering the broader impacts it could have on the future. He drew parallels to historical figures who revolutionized their fields by exploring neglected but crucial questions. Karnofsky believes that AI is a leading example of a transformative area that is not receiving the attention it warrants, advocating for more focus on AI's potential to shape the future 2 .

  3. Carl Shulman discussed the evolving awareness of AI risks among researchers. He mentioned that prominent figures in AI, like Jeff Hinton and Yoshua Bengio, have increasingly voiced concerns over AI's potential negative impacts. Shulman noted that while there has been progress in recognizing these risks, government actions and decisions on AI remain a critical area that may still lack proper attention and understanding 3 .

    Neglected AI, Chinese Intelligence

    Dominic emphasizes the lack of focus on AI and the need to pay attention to China's advancements in the field. He highlights the disinterest of politicians and the self-censorship within intelligence systems, hindering the potential for gathering valuable information.

    The Lunar Society

    Dominic Cummings - COVID, Brexit, & Fixing Western Governance
  4. Fin Moorhouse and Dwarkesh Patel touched on the broader theme of addressing neglected issues, indicating that effective innovation often comes from focusing on underserved areas. They highlighted the potential for significant advancements in AI by directing attention and resources to currently neglected aspects of AI development and alignment 4 .

In summary, there is a consensus among these discussions that AI, despite its transformative potential, might be neglected in terms of strategic focus, governmental attention, and broad societal engagement.