Why do social movements fail?

Social movements can fail for various reasons, largely related to organization, infrastructure, and the social environment they operate within.

1. Lack of Infrastructure: Movements fueled by social media often achieve rapid visibility and mobilization but may lack the necessary organizational infrastructure to sustain long-term efforts. This can leave them unprepared when facing governmental pushbacks or needing to transform visibility into tangible changes. As Zeynep Tufekci points out, the Gezi Park protests failed partly because they moved quickly without the foundational structures that would help them withstand repression 1.

2. Complex Social Dynamics: Even in democracies, social movements must navigate complex networks of influence and power. Sahar Heydari Fard emphasizes the importance of understanding the role of connections and support networks in amplifying change. Without strategic coordination and supportive connections, movements can struggle to maintain momentum or achieve their goals 2.

3. High Expectations and Visibility: Modern social movements may set unrealistic expectations due to the "sugar high" of achieving momentary visibility on social media. However, achieving long-lasting change requires grounded, on-the-ground organizing and legislative efforts, which are often neglected. Gal Beckerman notes that movements like Black Lives Matter achieve significant attention but sometimes falter in translating this into concrete legislative changes 3.

   • 

     1

     The Fizzling Out

     00:43:20
     
   • 

     2

     Social Movements Insight

     01:04:25
     
   • 

     3

     Social Movements Today

     00:41:44
   • 

     4

     Women in Movements

     00:34:40
     
   • 

     5

     Governance and Violence

     00:25:43
     
   • 

     6

     Redefining Social Constructs

     00:43:22
     

4. Internal Cohesion and Leadership: Successful social movements often require leaders willing to make personal sacrifices and adopt inclusive strategies. Sebastian Junger highlights how effective movements incorporate women into their organizational structures and frontline efforts. These strategies create resilient networks and broaden the movement's appeal. Additionally, leaders who are not willing to face personal risks can undermine the movement's credibility and effectiveness 4 5.

5. Cultural Resistance and Polarization: Changes proposed by social movements can encounter significant cultural resistance, especially when these changes threaten deeply rooted norms and power structures. Sally Haslanger explains that movements aiming to redefine social constructs, like race and gender, must navigate polarization and resistances that simple legislative or linguistic changes cannot overcome alone 6.

Together, these factors illustrate that while social movements can generate significant initial momentum, their long-term success depends on addressing these underlying challenges.