Warlike instinct
Sources:
The Warlike Instinct
Discussion Highlights
The concept of a "warlike instinct" suggests that some individuals or societies have an inherent drive towards combat and warfare. This idea is extensively explored by Jocko Willink in multiple episodes of the .
Key Points by Jocko Willink:
-
Instinctive Inclinations:
- Jocko remarks that some people have a higher natural inclination towards combat and warfare, similar to other instincts like parental or exploratory instincts. In his experiences with SEAL training, the focus is not on teaching but on identifying and honing these instincts in individuals who show a strong predisposition for warfare 1.
-
Genetic Component:
- There is a debate about whether the instinct to fight is purely a result of upbringing or has genetic roots. Jocko suggests that historically, those who were willing to fight and defend their tribe or resources were elevated within their societies. This elevation could suggest a deeply ingrained evolutionary advantage, fostering this fighting instinct in humans 2.
-
Combat as a Primal Instinct:
- Jocko, in conversation with Jordan Harbinger, describes combat as a primal human instinct. This inherent desire can lead people to join the military or participate in combat sports like MMA. The rush from conflict or war is deeply ingrained, sometimes leading individuals to seek out these experiences repeatedly 3.
Philosophical Perspective by Steven Pressfield:
Steven Pressfield provides a high-level philosophical view on war and its place in human nature. Discussing with Lex Fridman, he reflects on the ancient human dynamic of "us versus them," suggesting that humans are fundamentally the same as they were in tribal times. He proposes that this competitive and aggressive instinct might find healthier outlets in modern society through sports or other competitive but non-lethal activities 4.
Conclusion
The warlike instinct appears to be a blend of natural inclinations and evolutionary benefits that have been honed over centuries. While acknowledging its deep roots in human history, modern discussions suggest that it can be channelled into competitive yet constructive activities. This enables the fulfillment of these primal urges without the catastrophic consequences of war.
RELATED QUESTIONS-