Executive Branch

The powers and limitations of the Executive Branch, particularly the U.S. Presidency, have been a topic of discussion and debate among various experts. Here are some insights:

1. Ben Shapiro on Executive Power:

   • Shapiro explains that the Executive Branch, while having significant power, cannot unilaterally eliminate certain government departments established by Congress. The President can, however, fire personnel within departments and potentially influence funding by vetoing bills or not requesting funds for certain departments 1.
   • He also criticizes the increasing centralization of power in the Executive Branch, particularly in the context of handling crises like COVID-19. Shapiro argues that both political sides oscillate between demanding more power for the Executive when it suits them and criticizing it when it doesn't 2.

2. Unitary Executive Theory:

   • Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant discuss the "unitary executive theory," which posits that the Executive Branch, led by the President, holds extensive power within its domain, often resisting Congressional oversight. This theory has been tested in various political climates, reflecting ongoing tension between the branches of government 3.
     • 

       1

       Executive Branch Powers

       00:40:27
       
     • 

       2

       Executive Power Debate

       00:34:02
       
     • 

       3

       Executive Power Debate

       00:31:45
     • 

       4

       Presidential Power Debate

       00:57:36
     • 

       5

       The Power of the Presidency

       00:56:50
       
     • 

       6

       The Rise of Executive Power

       00:26:55

3. Constitutional Context:

   • Jay Wexler delves into the Constitution, noting that while the President has enumerated powers, these have been interpreted expansively over time. He highlights Congress's failure to assert its war-declaring powers and the courts' reluctance to mediate power disputes between Congress and the President 4.
   • Mike Lee and Jordan Peterson reflect on the emotional and divisive nature of the modern presidency, attributing it to the excessive concentration of power in the Executive Branch. They argue this has led to a contentious political environment, deviating from the intended balance of power 5.

4. Historical Perspectives:

   • Ben Shapiro discusses the continuous rise of Executive Branch power over the last century, warning against the precedent of bypassing legislative processes through national emergencies. He argues for upholding constitutional norms to prevent the overreach of any political party 6.

These discussions underscore the complexities and evolving dynamics of Executive power within the U.S. government, illustrating the ongoing struggle to balance authority among the branches.