Should advice be contextualized?


Yes, advice should be contextualized. Here's why, according to trusted experts:

  1. Personalization: stresses the importance of considering individuals' unique circumstances when giving advice. He uses the example of his own life context differing from a 44-year-old mother of two, indicating that what works for him may not be practical for her. He suggests meeting between optimal and practical solutions, emphasizing the need to tailor advice to fit the person's lifestyle and world which may be drastically different from one's own 1.

  2. Source and Expertise Consideration: advises considering the source and expertise of the person giving the advice. He mentions the need to contextualize advice based on the giver's background, as insights relevant to one profession or lifestyle may not be applicable to another. This caution helps align the advice better with one's own goals or circumstances 2.

  3. Evaluation of Context: argues that most advice can be highly subjective, often representing a narrow view based on personal experiences that might not universally apply. He suggests critically analyzing and inverting the advice to explore its applicability in different scenarios 3.

    Contextualized Advice

    Danny Matranga emphasizes the importance of considering individual contexts when giving advice. He discusses the common mistakes of not putting things into context and expecting others to start where you are. Danny highlights the significance of meeting in the middle of optimal and practical, and starting with small steps towards progress.

    Dynamic Dialogue with Danny Matranga

    131: How to *CONVINCE* Friends/Loved Ones to Live Healthier
  4. Questioning the Assumption Stack: emphasizes the importance of decoding advice by understanding the assumptions and perspectives behind it. He believes that advice must be absorbed contextually, encouraging individuals to dissect advice based on its relevance to their specific situations 4.

These expert opinions underscore the crucial role questioning context, personalization, and source credibility play in effectively utilizing advice.