Privately issued money

Privately issued money is a dynamic and complex topic, with various experts shedding light on its history, benefits, and challenges:

1. Historical Context and Benefits:

   • Gene Epstein discusses historical examples where banks issued privately backed currencies, especially during times like the War of 1812. He advocates for privately issued money backed by gold with 100% reserves, treating banks as warehouses for gold 1.

2. Current Perspectives and Regulation:

   • Rohan Grey explains the distinction between cryptocurrencies and stablecoins, emphasizing the need for government-issued money to ensure stability and safety. He argues that while private currencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum are not targeted by regulatory bills like the STABLE Act, the systemic risk of widespread adoption in day-to-day transactions necessitates government oversight 2.

3. Government Control and Market Failures:

   • Lawrence H. White highlights how governments historically took over private mints, often debasing the quality of coins. He points out that governments' fiscal motives drive such control, exploiting monopoly power over currency to generate revenue during times of fiscal need 3.
     
     1
     The Gold Standard
     00:34:17
     
     2
     Public Money vs Private Currency
     00:27:37
     
     3
     Private Mints, Government Control
     00:12:21
     
     4
     Private Money and Government Guarantee
     00:40:09
     
     5
     Money and Governance
     00:11:10

4. Economic Stability and Legal Dynamics:

   • Tyler Cowen discusses the role of government guarantees in private money. He explains how deposit insurance underpins the stability of private bank checks, suggesting that removing such guarantees would lead to instability. He underscores the historical reasons for government-issued money, such as seigniorage, and explores legal and cultural barriers to adopting alternative currencies 4.

5. Private Money and Public Governance:

   • In terms of governance, Rohan Grey reiterates that money is a tool of public governance and a creature of law. He notes that through history, money has always carried a relationship to state validation and enforcement, reflecting legal governance even in private transactions 5.

These insights underscore that while privately issued money holds potential benefits, it requires robust regulatory frameworks to ensure stability and prevent systemic risks. The balance between innovation and regulation remains a key point of discussion among experts.