Should media organizations take sides?

Experts have different opinions on whether media organizations should take sides.

Against Taking Sides:

• Jeff Krasno argues that the media has a foundational role in democracy by providing unbiased information. He points out that during the 2020 U.S. elections, media outlets maintained integrity by reporting factual vote counts, which helped to debunk false election fraud claims. Krasno emphasizes the importance of conservative and liberal media presenting factual information to protect the democratic process 1.

Critical of Media Bias:

• Ben Shapiro criticizes the media for acting as activists rather than impartial reporters. He highlights how media pressure can influence corporate actions, as seen when a small number of MLB players influenced the relocation of an All-Star game through media-driven corporate pressure 2.

Promoting Media Taking Stands:

• Bill George discusses how businesses often take stands on social issues that matter to their stakeholders, arguing that such actions are necessary for addressing broader societal concerns. Although this perspective focuses on business ethics, it implies that media organizations, like businesses, might also have roles in supporting important social causes 3.

  Election Reality Check

  Jeff Krasno

  Trump attempted to create a false narrative of victory on election night, despite the reality of the vote count. The media, including conservative outlets, played a crucial role in maintaining integrity by accurately reporting the ongoing tally of votes. Ultimately, the election results were determined by numbers, debunking Trump’s claims of widespread fraud and highlighting the contradictions in his narrative.

  

  Commune with Jeff Krasno

  140. Commusings: Democracy Is Fragile

  Explore similar conversationsView full episode summary

  1

  2

  3

  4

Nuanced View:

• Mary Katharine Ham recognizes the complexity of the media as an evolving institution. She suggests that while free speech and raucous debate should be cornerstones of journalism, media organizations must navigate and adapt to changing cultural and economic forces 4.

These perspectives underscore the debate within the media industry about balancing impartial reporting with taking stands on critical issues.