Equity System

Equity systems refer to frameworks aiming to ensure fair treatment by focusing on outcomes rather than just providing equal opportunities. Here are some perspectives from various experts on this concept:

1. Ben Shapiro's Views on Equity:

   • Ben Shapiro distinguishes between equality and equity, emphasizing that equality involves equal rights and treatment by law, while equity implies that any inequality must result from discrimination. He argues that equity, rooted in critical race theory and postmodernism, views societal structures as inherently perpetuating power imbalances. This perspective, according to him, undermines individual responsibility and aligns disturbingly with white supremacist ideologies that suggest certain groups cannot make free decisions due to systemic oppression 1 2.

2. Discussion on Equity in Education:

   • During a discussion about the "Equity in the Education System Act" on the Jordan B. Peterson Podcast, concerns were raised about how policies advocating for equity might affect the education system. The conversation highlighted the importance of critically evaluating such legislation and its implications for fairness in education 3.
     • 

       1

       Wokism and Its Impact

       01:49:00
       
     • 

       2

       Equity Ideology Critique

       00:02:13
       
     • 

       3

       Equity in Education

       00:01:35
       
     • 

       4

       Equity and Speed

       00:47:51
     • 

       5

       Power and Ideology

       00:11:15
       

3. Dr. Nadine Burke Harris on Equity and Speed:

   • In an episode of The Ezra Klein Show, Dr. Nadine Burke Harris argued that equity can actually enhance efficiency, particularly in public health measures like vaccination distribution. By targeting resources to communities with the highest disease burden, the overall public health response can be more effective and quicker, demonstrating how equity considerations can align with practical outcomes 4.

4. Ideologies Driving Equity Initiatives:

   • Shapiro also critiques the broader ideological underpinnings of equity initiatives, especially in contexts like diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs. He sees these initiatives as placing undue emphasis on power dynamics to explain societal inequalities, which can lead to divisive and sometimes extreme conclusions about societal structures 5.

These discussions reveal the complexity of equity systems, showing how they can be viewed both as tools for addressing systemic inequalities and as ideologically driven narratives that might undermine personal responsibility and societal cohesion.