Should autonomy be regulated?

Sources:

Expert opinions suggest that certain forms of autonomy, such as autonomous vehicles and weapons, should indeed be regulated, while pointing to the need for a balanced and thoughtful approach:

  • Autonomous Vehicles (AVs): Experts including argue for intelligent national regulation to reduce accidents and improve public confidence, highlighting a slow adoption timeline due to safety concerns 1. Additionally, emphasizes the necessity for federal rather than state-level standards to ensure consistency and safety 2.

  • Autonomous Weapons: stresses the importance of regulating autonomous weapons to prevent negative outcomes, paralleling it to the successful regulation of chemical and biological weapons. He underscores the difficulty in regulation due to the ease of clandestine development but insists on its necessity to avoid potential dangers 3.

    Regulation of Autonomous Vehicles

    The discussion highlights the necessity of smart national regulation for autonomous vehicles, especially during a transitional phase marked by recent accidents. Concerns about public perception and the potential for an AI winter are raised, emphasizing the importance of balancing state and federal oversight. Experts suggest that without proper regulation, the industry could face significant setbacks, as the timeline for widespread adoption of autonomous technology is projected to be much longer than some optimistic forecasts.
    AI Today Podcast: Artificial Intelligence Insights, Experts, and Opinion
    AI Today Podcast #35: Interview with Tom Davenport, Babson College, MIT, and Deloitte — Augmented Intelligence, GDPR, Data Science, and More
    1
    2
    3

Overall, the consensus is that while autonomy brings many benefits, appropriate regulation is crucial to ensure safety and address potential risks, especially in critical areas like transportation and defense.

RELATED QUESTIONS