Is discipline about coercion?
Sources:
Discipline is often misconceived as coercion, but it doesn't inherently mean that. In addressing common misinterpretations, explains that self-imposed discipline is about autonomy and the freedom to pursue challenging but important goals voluntarily. Newport asserts that when discipline is exercised by choice, it is the essence of freedom rather than the negation of it 1.
Furthermore, emphasizes that discipline should not be viewed as taking options away or being rigidly stuck in a pattern. Instead, it's about the human capability to accept and tackle hardship voluntarily for long-term benefits. This form of self-discipline is critical in making progress toward significant goals 2.
Similarly, argues that coercive discipline, particularly in raising children, is harmful as it stifles their ability to pursue their passions wholeheartedly. She highlights that genuine self-discipline, as seen in athletes or musicians, comes from intrinsic motivation and passion rather than external coercion 3.
Hence, discipline, especially when self-imposed, is more about freedom and autonomy than coercion.
RELATED QUESTIONS
