Can AI systems create something new?

AI systems have shown impressive capabilities in emulating creative processes and producing novel outputs. However, the consensus among experts is that while AI can mimic and combine existing styles in innovative ways, it still struggles with generating fundamentally new art forms or creative concepts from scratch.

Key Points:

1. Emulated Creativity:

   • Kai-Fu Lee argues that AI can emulate styles like Mozart or Picasso but can't create a new, unique style that appeals to human emotions in the way genuinely original human art does. AI can modify existing elements creatively but doesn't generate completely new ones 1.
   • Yejin Choi also supports this view, explaining that AI creates output by juxtaposing known patterns in new ways, which may seem novel but fundamentally are assembled from existing human-created patterns 2.

2. AI-Driven Discoveries:

   • AI can connect dots across vast amounts of previously published information, potentially leading to new insights or "new" creations based on extensive data analysis. This capability is highlighted by Brian Roemmele, who mentions AI's ability to link diverse academic fields for groundbreaking discoveries 3.
     • 

       1

       AI and Creativity

       00:08:03
     • 

       2

       AI Creativity Insights

       00:36:46
       
     • 

       3

       AI and Human Discovery

       00:48:28
     • 

       4

       AI Creativity

       00:37:18
     • 

       5

       The Potential of AI

       01:19:39
     • 

       6

       The Future of AI Art

       01:22:40
     • 

       7

       AI Creativity Debate

       00:15:42
       

3. AI in Game Design:

   • Jonathan Strickland discusses AI like Angelina, which designs unique game concepts that humans might not think of, suggesting that AI can indeed contribute novel ideas within specific contexts, though often by recombining existing elements in unexpected ways 4.

4. Creative Capabilities of AI:

   • Dr. Brian Keating and James Altucher debate whether AI can create something entirely new, like inventing the game of chess. They agree that AI might design new games by understanding and exploring fun aspects of existing games, although this remains an experimental area 5.

5. Challenges and Potential:

   • Eric Jang envisions AI agents providing inspiration for new stories by living out simulated lives, possibly leading to creative outputs beyond human imagination. Yet, he warns that the proliferation of AI-created art could diminish traditional forms, like how 3D animation supplanted 2D animation in mainstream media 6.
   • Marc Andreessen and Ben Horowitz highlight the current limitations, noting that AI hasn't yet matched the ability to create truly non-fungible, iconic works like "The Godfather" or unique music albums 7.

In summary, while AI can perform impressive feats of emulated creativity and drive forward new combinations of existing elements, its ability to create something fundamentally new and unique still lags behind human ingenuity.