Is transgenderism a mental disorder?
Sources:
Transgenderism, specifically described as gender dysphoria, is a topic with various perspectives on whether it constitutes a mental disorder.
asserts that gender dysphoria is indeed a mental disorder, citing the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5). He critiques the DSM-5's approach for being influenced by political correctness and redefining criteria to avoid labeling it as a disorder directly unless it causes significant distress or impairment 1 2 3.
Conversely, warns against framing transgender identities purely in terms of mental health issues. He argues that the mental health struggles faced by transgender individuals often stem from societal treatment rather than being inherently linked to their transgender status 4.
regards gender dysphoria as a mental illness, likening it to other conditions where individuals have distress about body perception, such as anorexia or bulimia. He suggests that acknowledging and addressing this as a disorder is necessary for providing effective help 5.
These viewpoints highlight a significant divide in how gender dysphoria and transgender identities are conceptualized, with some seeing it as a mental health issue requiring treatment and others emphasizing the role of societal factors in the well-being of transgender individuals.
RELATED QUESTIONS
