Is the Chinese economy a threat?

The Chinese economy's perceived threat varies among experts, from viewing China as an imminent danger to advocating for a nuanced understanding of its geopolitical and economic influence.

Points Highlighting China as a Threat:

1. Expansionist Policies: Ben Shapiro argues that Xi Jinping's pursuit of state reassertion domestically and an aggressive foreign policy increases China's threat, particularly due to Taiwan's proximity. He advocates for increased military buildup in response to China's broadening influence 1.
2. Economic Leverage: Shapiro also mentions that China uses its vast population and market power to pressure corporations and advance its strategic interests, likening it to a geopolitical maneuver similar to Russia's actions. He suggests addressing this threat through economic strategies, similar to how the US handled the Soviet Union 2.
3. Geopolitical Power Balance: David Friedberg notes that while China's economic collapse would have global repercussions due to intertwined economies, China's growth translates directly into increased military might, making it a potential threat to neighbors and regions like Taiwan 3.
   • 

     1

     The China Threat

     00:58:32
   • 

     2

     China's Economic Power

     00:28:10
   • 

     3

     China's Economic Impact

     01:03:38
   • 

     4

     China's Geopolitical Challenge

     01:00:57
   • 

     5

     China's Geopolitical Role

     01:01:07
   • 

     6

     Economic Growth Paranoia

     00:57:18

Points Arguing Against Viewing China as a Direct Threat:

1. Internal Challenges: Both Shapiro and Noam Chomsky highlight China's internal weaknesses, such as a declining birth rate and economic vulnerabilities. These internal issues could limit China's aggressive strategies and necessitate a focus on domestic stability over external expansion 2 4.
2. Diplomacy and Negotiation: Chomsky advocates dealing with China's expansionist policies, like in the South China Sea, through diplomacy rather than perceiving them as an imminent threat. He emphasizes understanding the complexities and not viewing China's actions in isolation from similar actions by other global powers, including the US 5 4.
3. Economic Interdependence: Don Boudreaux and Russ Roberts argue that economic activity is inherently cooperative rather than competitive. They believe that China's economic growth should not be seen as a zero-sum game that threatens the US, but rather a scenario where both can thrive without detriment to each other 6.

Conclusion:

There is a split in perspectives regarding China as a threat due to its economic and military growth. While some like Ben Shapiro see a need for immediate and strong responses to counter China's influence, others like Noam Chomsky and Don Boudreaux suggest that China's rise should be managed through diplomacy and recognizing economic interdependence rather than direct confrontation.