What was the rule of engagement?

The "rules of engagement" (ROE) in military contexts are essentially directives that outline how military personnel must conduct themselves during operations. They cover what is permitted in terms of engaging the enemy under different conditions, aiming to minimize unnecessary harm and maintain moral and legal boundaries.

Key Points Discussed by Podcast Experts:

1. Fundamental Principles:

   • According to Jocko Willink on the Jocko Podcast, the ROE allows necessary and proportional force in self-defense 1.
   • The enemy often exploited these rules, as they do not adhere to any ROE themselves 2.

2. Ethics and Strategy:

   • Adhering to ROE is crucial not just for moral and ethical reasons, but also for strategic purposes, protecting both the troops and civilian populations while achieving military objectives 3.
     • 

       1

       Rules of Engagement

       00:08:32
       
     • 

       2

       Rules of Engagement

       01:49:05
       
     • 

       3

       Rules of Engagement

       00:19:47
       
     • 

       4

       Rules of Engagement

       02:31:16
       
     • 

       5

       Rules of Engagement

       01:07:00
       
     • 

       6

       Rules of Engagement

       02:06:18
       
     • 

       7

       Rules of Engagement

       00:41:47
       

3. Challenges in Implementation:

   • There are significant challenges when fighting insurgents who blend with civilians and employ tactics like using human shields, which complicates adherence to ROE 4.
   • Strict ROE can sometimes restrict actions, leading to higher casualties, but proper training and leadership can mitigate this issue 5.

4. Leadership's Role:

   • The enforcement and interpretation of ROE often boil down to leadership decisions. Leaders must clearly communicate and delegate decisions to ensure combat effectiveness within the ROE framework 6 7.

Following and understanding these principles ensures the troops' actions are within legal and ethical boundaries, enhancing both their safety and mission success.