What are the benefits of eating meat like chicken and fish? What are the disadvantages
Sources:
Benefits of Eating Meat (Chicken and Fish)
Cognitive Health: Animal products like fish, beef, chicken, and dairy have been associated with reduced risk of cognitive decline, dementia, and Alzheimer's disease. Choline, found in animal products, is linked to reduced cognitive decline risk [1].
Protein Balance: While excessive animal protein can negatively impact bowel health, good sources like fish and chicken are recommended in moderate amounts. Fish, rich in healthy fats and omega-3 fatty acids, is crucial for reproductive health and brain function [2].
Omega-3 Fatty Acids: Fish provides a preformed omega-3 fatty acids like DHA, which is thought to have been critical for brain growth in human evolution. Red meat and organ meats, part of our ancestors' diets, also provide nutrients essential for brain health [3].
Reproductive Health: Tofu and fish positively impact fertility and provide nutrients like iron and omega-3 fatty acids. Three servings of fish per week are recommended [4].
Disadvantages of Eating Meat
Bowel Health: Excessive intake of red or processed meats isn't great for the bowel and can lead to foul-smelling gas due to fermentation by harmful bacteria [2].
Disease Risks: Studies suggest a connection between animal protein and increased risk of heart disease, diabetes, cancer, stroke, and chronic kidney disease. TMAO, a compound found in the blood after consuming red meat, is strongly linked to coronary artery disease and other conditions [5].
Nutrient Profile: Chicken is relatively nutrient-poor compared to red meat and may not be the health pick it's often believed to be. It also contains a mix of fats, including those found in olive oil, contradicting the common belief that it lacks saturated fats [6].
Overall, there's evidence suggesting both health benefits and risks associated with consuming meats like chicken and fish. It's important to consider the balance of one's diet and consult healthcare professionals for personalized advice.
RELATED QUESTIONSWhat about red meat?
Sources:
Benefits of Eating Red Meat
- Nutritional Value: Red meat, such as quality steak or ground beef, is considered to be very nutrient-dense, providing an excellent source of protein, B vitamins, iron, and other micronutrients needed for good health. It is notably rich in creatine and has been observed to improve strength and athletic performance when included in the diet [1].
- Hormonal Balance: Women with menstrual irregularities and hormonal imbalances have benefited from increasing their consumption of good quality red meat, with improvements in their overall well-being noted [2].
- Muscle Building: Consuming red meat has been associated with performance gains in the gym. Athletes and bodybuilders have long observed that red meat helps in building muscle mass, likely due to its amino acid profile, creatine content, and overall protein boost [3].
Disadvantages of Eating Red Meat
- Carcinogenic Risk: Processed red meats, such as hot dogs and deli meats that contain sodium nitrite as a preservative, are associated with the formation of potentially carcinogenic nitroso compounds. These are thought to be inflammatory and increase cancer risks. However, this risk can be mitigated by choosing meats without added nitrites and ensuring a diet rich in antioxidants [4].
- Cholesterol Levels: Red meat does contain fatty acids that can raise apolipoprotein B (apoB), although this effect can be balanced with the consumption of fibrous vegetables and other heart-healthy dietary practices. Grass-fed and grass-finished meats are leaner and have a more balanced fat profile that may have a neutral effect on blood lipids [5].
- Healthy User Bias: There's a tendency to find links in observational studies that do not control for diet quality. Red meat often gets a bad reputation due to its association with unhealthy diets high in processed foods and lacking in fruits and vegetables. Newer studies that control for diet quality show no negative impact, and some find benefits due to its high nutrient density and role in addressing global issues like iron deficiency anemia [6].
In conclusion, while there are concerns related to the consumption of processed red meats, quality red meat that is not heavily processed may have several health benefits when included as part of a balanced diet. It is recommended that red meat should be sourced responsibly (preferably grass-fed and organic) and consumed in moderation to maximize its health benefits while minimizing potential risks.
RELATED QUESTIONS