What is enlightened centrism?

"Enlightened centrism" is often used pejoratively to describe a stance that claims a moral or intellectual high ground by positioning oneself above traditional partisan politics. Rather than actively supporting either side, it suggests that both sides are equally flawed and that true wisdom lies in distancing oneself from partisan conflict.

David Pakman mentions that enlightened centrism reflects a desire to appear above the fray, usually presenting both political sides as equally corrupt and ineffective 1. He argues that this stance often stifles meaningful conversation and can indirectly lead to lower voter turnout by promoting political apathy.

Tim Urban elaborates that people accused of being enlightened centrists, like Steven Pinker and Jonathan Haidt, are often viewed as detached intellectuals who avoid taking firm stances 2. He argues that those who adopt this stance miss the nuance in various issues and can be seen as not committing to substantial political actions.