Vanguard vs. Fidelity vs. TRO Price?

When comparing Vanguard, Fidelity, and T. Rowe Price, there are several key points to consider based on insights from Brad Barrett:

1. Low-Cost Index Funds:

   • Vanguard is highly favored in the financial independence community for their low-cost index funds and investor-first ethos. The company consistently reduces costs as their mission aligns with benefiting investors rather than profit margins 1 2.
   • Fidelity offers competitive low-cost index funds, including some zero-fee funds. However, there have been concerns about hidden fees and practices not being fully transparent, which has led to federal and state investigations 3 4.
     • 

       1

       Cost of Investing

       00:36:22
       
     • 

       2

       Vanguard's Dominance

       00:20:08
       
     • 

       3

       Index Fund Insights

       00:42:25
       
     • 

       4

       Avoiding Investment Fees

       00:49:50
       
     • 

       5

       Index Fund Insights

       00:47:34
       
     • 

       6

       Index Fund Insights

       00:22:49
       
   • T. Rowe Price, like most other investment firms, operates with profit motives, balancing investor benefits and shareholder returns. While they offer quality funds, their primary obligation is to their shareholders 1.

2. Fees and Ethical Practices:

   • Vanguard's structure inherently limits investor costs. Any potential profit would be returned to investors, keeping fees low 1.
   • Fidelity introduced zero-fee index funds, but underlying costs may still exist, and the sustainability of zero-fee offerings is questioned 3 2.
   • T. Rowe Price may offer slightly higher fees compared to Vanguard and Fidelity, focusing on balanced profitability for shareholders and investors 1.

3. Investment Strategies:

   • Brad Barrett and JL Collins suggest that the actual performance difference between similar offerings from these firms, like total stock market index funds, will be minor. The slight edge one offers over the other can vary over time and is often negligible in the long term 3 5 6.

4. Practical Advice:

   • For those holding accounts across multiple firms, it is noted to avoid incurring unnecessary fees by sticking with ETFs like VTI (Vanguard) over mutual funds like VTSAX if not directly using Vanguard accounts. This helps evade transaction fees when dealing in external brokerage accounts 4.
   • Fidelity's user interface and customer service are appreciated by many investors, indicating a preference not only based on cost but also on usability and service quality 5.

Overall, while Vanguard is often seen as the leader due to its low fees and investor-prioritized structure, both Fidelity and T. Rowe Price also offer competitive products. The choice often comes down to individual preferences for cost transparency, service quality, and ethical business practices. Investing in low-cost broad-based index funds is the core recommendation across these platforms.