Learn more
Join Dexa

  • transgender running

  • Sources:

    The inclusion of transgender individuals in running and other sports is a complex topic with various viewpoints and research findings. Here are some key insights from experts:

    The Impact of Hormone Therapy

    1. Joanna Harper, a transgender athlete and researcher, observed changes in her own running performance and conducted a study to track race times of trans women runners before and after hormone therapy. She found that, on average, these runners lost their male advantage after transitioning, becoming similarly competitive against women as they were against men before transitioning 1 2.
    2. However, some studies indicate that even after hormone therapy, trans women may retain some physical advantages, such as larger muscle mass and strength acquired during male puberty 2.

    Debating Fairness in Competition

    1. Malcolm Gladwell highlighted the significance of small performance advantages in competitive sports. He described a journalist's underestimation of testosterone benefits, emphasizing that even a small percentage difference can determine the outcome in athletic competitions 3.
    2. Ben Shapiro discussed the case of C C Telfer, a transgender track star who dominated women's track and field events. He argued that physical advantages from male puberty, like height and musculature, can still be significant despite hormone therapy 4.

    Policy and Inclusion

    1. The Biden administration's policies, including the extension of Title IX to include transgender individuals, aim to protect transgender athletes' rights but have sparked debate over the implications for women's sports 5.
    2. David Epstein suggested that the fairness of including transgender athletes might depend on the specific sport. He mentioned that cardiovascular changes post-transition align more closely with female norms, while strength and bone density advantages from male puberty might persist in strength-intensive sports 6.

    Personal Experiences

    1. Cynthia Monteleone, an athlete and coach, shared her experience and concerns about competing against transgender athletes. She mentioned the competitive advantages seen in track events and highlighted broader safety and fairness issues 7.

    In summary, while hormone therapy can significantly impact transgender athletes' performance, residual physical advantages from male puberty raise ongoing debates about fairness in sports. The extent of these advantages and appropriate policies continue to be subjects of research and discussion.

    RELATED QUESTIONS