Are trigger warnings harmful?

The debate around trigger warnings highlights some potential issues and varied perspectives from experts.

1. Ineffectiveness and Potential Harm: Studies suggest trigger warnings may not be beneficial and could even be counterproductive by increasing anxiety. For instance, Ben Shapiro cites research indicating that trigger warnings neither help nor harm but can make some people less resilient to trauma 1. Similarly, Dr. Phil emphasizes that trigger warnings can create more anxiety and don’t prepare individuals for real-world stressors 2.

2. Psychological Perspective: Tracy Dennis-Tiwary, a clinical psychologist, notes that trigger warnings might send a message that individuals are too vulnerable to handle difficult emotions, which could be counterproductive from a clinical standpoint 3.

   • 

     1

     Trigger Warning Debate

     00:23:30
     
   • 

     2

     Trigger Warnings Debate

     01:34:28
     
   • 

     3

     Rethinking Trigger Warnings

     00:11:49
   • 

     4

     Trigger Warnings

     01:01:08
   • 

     5

     The Fragility of Young Minds

     00:07:25
   • 

     6

     Privilege and Fear

     00:19:20
     

3. Exposure Therapy: Both Jonathan Haidt and Dr. Phil argue that facing fears and difficult situations through methods like exposure therapy is more effective. Haidt explains that exposure therapy helps individuals overcome trauma by gradually desensitizing them to words, stories, and images 4.

4. Cultural Shift and Coddling: Experts like Lenore Skenazy and Adam Schafer discuss the broader cultural trend towards overprotection, which they argue makes young people more fragile and less resilient. This cultural shift might contribute to the increased demand for trigger warnings, but it arguably undermines the development of resilience 5 6.

Overall, the consensus among these experts is that trigger warnings may not be as helpful as intended and could potentially foster greater anxiety and sensitivity.