AGI Control Problem

The AGI control problem focuses on the challenge of managing superintelligent artificial intelligence whose goals may misalign with human values. This concern involves both the alignment problem, which deals with ensuring the AI's goals match ours, and the control or containment problem, which addresses how to keep the AI confined despite potential outsmarting capabilities.

• Alignment and Containment: In an analogy given by Stephen West, imagine a superintelligence compared to humans as an adult to five-year-old children. This perspective highlights not only the difficulty of containment but also the challenge of appropriately guiding the AI without it manipulating or overriding human control. This analogy also brings to light the imperative of addressing both the alignment of goals and effective containment strategies 1.

• Development and Ethics: Chris Williamson discusses the importance of establishing aligned goals in AGI systems before granting them operational power. He compares current societal shifts to the potential risks of empowering AGI systems without a solid ethical foundation, suggesting that rapid advances in technology could lead to ethical degradation if not properly managed 2.

• Risks and Loss of Control: Max Tegmark raises concerns about the pace of AI development potentially leading to scenarios where humans cannot control superintelligent AI. He notes that while current AI safety measures are intended to prevent such outcomes, the rapid progress in AI capabilities might outpace these safety efforts 3.

  • 

    1

    The Control Problem

    00:24:51
  • 

    2

    Control and Technology

    01:04:23
    
  • 

    3

    Control and AGI

    00:50:53
    
  • 

    4

    Controlling AGI

    00:23:14

• Practical Control Solutions: There's some skepticism about whether simplistic control methods (like unplugging the AI) would suffice in the face of a truly advanced AGI. This skepticism suggests more nuanced strategies are necessary to ensure that AI does not become too powerful or act contrary to human interests 4.

In conclusion, experts discuss the AGI control problem as an ongoing and complex challenge that involves ensuring that AI's goals are aligned with human values and that mechanisms are in place to maintain control over AI's capabilities. This problem is not only theoretical but practical, urging immediate consideration as AI technology advances.