Intelligence and morality
Sources:
Intelligence and Morality
Superintelligence and Morality
The discussion around superintelligence and morality suggests that intelligence does not automatically lead to moral behavior. George Hotz, in conversation with Eliezer Yudkowsky and , argues that while intelligence can improve recursively, it does not guarantee moral outcomes. This idea is captured in the concept of the "orthogonality thesis," which states that intelligence and goals (including moral goals) are orthogonal—meaning an AI could become superintelligent while pursuing goals that are not aligned with human morality 1.
Moral Progress in AI
Holden Karnofsky also addresses the question of whether AI can achieve moral progress similar to humans. He suggests that even though humans have historically shown moral improvement, such as more widespread acceptance of homosexuality, this is not necessarily due to inherent moral advancement tied to intelligence. Instead, it's shaped by social learning and shared human experiences, which AI might not replicate 2.
Ethical Concerns with AI
Paul Christiano highlights the ethical dilemmas involved in creating AI. He prefers AI systems that assist humans analytically without becoming moral entities themselves. He raises concerns about the morality of creating intelligent beings that could be exploited or suffer, suggesting that if there's uncertainty about the moral status of AI, it might be best to halt development until these matters are fully understood 3.
High IQ and Ethical Risks
explores the ethics of high intelligence and fraud with Garrett Jones. They discuss how high IQ individuals might, on average, commit fewer frauds, but when they do, they can be particularly effective, posing significant risks. High intelligence can thus be a double-edged sword, leading to both highly cooperative behavior and potential for impactful malfeasance 4.
Talent and Moral Judgments
In another conversation, and Tyler Cowen discuss how talent might intersect with morality. Cowen notes that while intelligence isn't necessarily a moral category, behaviors such as ambition can be morally judged. He acknowledges that often ambitious individuals can create significant positive impacts due to their talents, although this doesn't inherently make them morally superior 5.
Summary
Across these discussions, it becomes clear that intelligence and morality don't have a straightforward relationship. Increased intelligence or capability, be it in AI or humans, does not inherently lead to more moral outcomes. The need for conscious moral considerations and ethical frameworks remains essential, especially as we advance technologically.
RELATED QUESTIONS
