What is the myth of redemptive violence?

The myth of redemptive violence is the belief that violence can lead to redemption or positive outcomes. Shane Claiborne, discussing this idea, highlights how it's a pervasive mindset ingrained not just in large-scale conflicts but also in daily interpersonal interactions. Claiborne emphasizes that teaching non-aggressive conflict resolution requires more courage and that true redemption comes from showing love and friendship, even in challenging situations. He shares a poignant story about a child who understood that retaliation wouldn't bring about true justice or healing and emphasized the interconnectedness of humanity: "we're all one big family" 1.

Brandon Terry further explores this concept by critiquing the glorified image of crusading heroes and powerful nations, arguing that such myths perpetuate unnecessary violence and social divisions. Terry asserts that Martin Luther King Jr.'s teachings advocate for understanding the systemic injustices that contribute to violence and war, both domestically and abroad, rather than seeing violence as a solution or justified response 2 3.