• Natural hierarchies

  • Sources:

    The concept of natural hierarchies is multifaceted and often debated across different contexts. Here are several expert perspectives on the topic:

    1. Differing Views on Hierarchies: Louise Perry and Mary Harrington discuss how ideological divides, particularly between political left and right, influence perceptions of hierarchies. The left may reject the notion of inherent hierarchies, viewing them as constructs that can and should be overcome with technology or social reforms. Meanwhile, the right often sees certain hierarchies, such as parental authority over children, as natural and necessary1 2.

    2. Anarchism and Hierarchies: Michael Malice and Lex Fridman explore whether hierarchies form naturally among humans, even in anarchic or non-state settings. They argue that while certain hierarchies are inevitable, such as those based on expertise or voluntary associations, anarchism isn’t about the absence of hierarchy but rather about relationships and voluntary interactions where power isn’t coercive3.

    3. Biological Basis and Ethical Sense: Jordan Peterson discusses how hierarchical structures may evolve around ethical principles that enhance stability and productivity over long periods. These hierarchies might emerge naturally and influence social dynamics and mate selection, suggesting a biological underpinning to certain ethical behaviors and social structures4.

    4. Impact on Outcomes: Louise Perry examines whether different outcomes among groups, like gender or ethnic disparities, stem from natural hierarchies or social constructs. This distinction affects how society views and addresses inequality, with some seeing hierarchies as inherently bad while others view them as a natural aspect of human organization5.

    5. Flattening Hierarchies in Professional Settings: Jason Mendelson and Jonathan Fields discuss "flattening hierarchies" in professional contexts, emphasizing the importance of recognizing individual strengths and backgrounds. They suggest that everyone brings unique value to an organization, which can help mitigate hierarchical barriers and foster trust and inclusivity6.

    These insights illustrate the complexity and varying interpretations of natural hierarchies across ideological, biological, and professional dimensions.

    RELATED QUESTIONS