Do brain training games work?

Brain training games, while popular, have mixed evidence supporting their effectiveness. Here are some insights from experts on the topic:

1. Focused Benefits: Opher Brayer notes anecdotal successes with brain-training games, such as improving cognitive performance in underdeveloped students 1. However, this evidence is not thoroughly academically validated.

2. Limited Real-World Transfer: According to Ariel Garten, brain-training games tend to improve performance in specific tasks but often do not translate these gains to real-world cognitive functions, except for some exceptions like the NBAC game, which aids memory retrieval 2.

3. Scientific Validation Issues: Adam Gazzaley emphasizes that while brain games rest on solid scientific principles like plasticity and challenge, many do not undergo rigorous scientific validation to prove their efficacy beyond the game environment 3.

   Brain Games Impact

   Katie Wells

   Opher Brayer

   Opher discusses the transformative effects of brain games on cognitive connections, highlighting their surprising success with underdeveloped students in competitions. He emphasizes that these games are beneficial for all ages, even extending to elderly participants, and challenges the notion that IQ is the sole measure of success in life.

   

   The Wellness Mama Podcast

   264: Opher Brayer on Creating Polymaths Using Games of Genius

   Explore similar conversationsView full episode summary

   1

   2

   3

   4

   5

4. Compartmentalized Improvement: Adrian Owen found in a large study that while brain training can improve specific practiced tasks, it does not necessarily enhance broader cognitive abilities. People became better at the trained tasks but did not show improved performance in unrelated cognitive domains 4.

5. Practical Applications and Limits: Andrew Huberman highlights that mental training, including visualization, can be beneficial, especially for maintaining skills during physical injuries. However, real-world physical practice is more effective overall than mental training or brain games alone 5.

In summary, while brain training games can improve specific cognitive tasks, their benefits often do not extend significantly beyond these tasks. Robust scientific validation and focusing on holistic brain exercises like meditation or practical learning scenarios tend to show more comprehensive cognitive benefits.