Episode 76: Special Episode on the Patterns Journal

Workshop Process

The Patterns Journal emphasizes the importance of workshopping papers at specific conferences before submission. James Noble explains that papers must be workshopped at Hillside-sponsored PLoP conferences to ensure they represent the best work in software patterns 1. This requirement aims to elevate the quality and recognition of published work.

The journal is about publishing and collecting and recognizing the very best work that's done in patterns for software and for other things.

--- James Noble

This approach replaces the older PLoPdy book series, offering a more timely and accessible platform for pattern literature.

   

Review Standards

The Patterns Journal sets high standards for its review process, distinguishing itself from the more welcoming PLoP conferences. Ralph Johnson notes that while PLoP conferences are friendly and inclusive, the journal aims for rigorous reviews to create great literature 2. Authors may face multiple review rounds before acceptance, reflecting the journal's commitment to quality.

The journal is going to be a bit more like a journal and we're going to have high standards and we're going to reject lots of papers.

--- Ralph Johnson

This process ensures that only the most refined and impactful papers are published, advancing the field of software patterns.