The Problem With Secular Architecture - Jonathan Pageau

Icons & Idols

The distinction between icons and idols is a significant theological concept explored by Jonathan Pageau. He explains that icons serve as windows to the divine, pointing beyond themselves to higher truths, while idols become ends in themselves, capturing attention without leading to transcendence 1. Alex J O'Connor adds that this distinction is crucial in understanding how religious symbols function in society. Pageau notes that modern society often confuses these concepts, leading to a misinterpretation of religious language 2.

The difference between an icon and idol is that the icon affords the transcendent. It is not something which stops at itself, but rather leads up towards higher participation.

--- Jonathan Pageau

This misunderstanding can result in a loss of connection to ancient ways of thinking, making religious language seem outdated or irrelevant.

   

Secular Idolatry

Modern society's creation and worship of idols is a reflection of secular values, according to Jonathan Pageau. He argues that things like alcohol and pornography can become idols when they capture our full attention, diverting us from higher purposes 3. Alex J O'Connor questions what it means to worship something in this context, to which Pageau responds that worship is the highest point of attention, not fitting into a higher good. This secular idolatry is often misunderstood due to a lack of understanding of spiritual concepts, leading to a superficial grasp of religious ideas 4.

The best way to understand worship is you could say that it is the highest point of your attention.

--- Jonathan Pageau

This highlights the need for a deeper comprehension of how religious and secular values intersect in modern life.