s4/e25 “Why Am I Gaining Weight During Marathon Training?” and Other Questions About Weight & Body Composition with Holley Samuel, RD

Topics covered
Popular Clips
Questions from this episode
- Asked by 63 people
- Asked by 38 people
- Asked by 13 people
- Asked by 12 people
- Asked by 8 people
- Asked by 3 people
- Asked by 3 people
- Asked by 2 people
- Asked by 1 person
- Asked by 1 person
- Asked by 1 person
Episode Highlights
Health Goals
Balancing health goals with fitness performance requires a realistic approach to goal-setting. Samuel Holley emphasizes that peak fitness isn't sustainable year-round and that blood work often looks better during off-seasons when life is more balanced 1. She advises that if maintaining an ideal body weight requires food restriction, it might not be the healthiest weight for you. Holley also suggests seeking alternative advice if medical opinions don't align with personal health experiences, as biases can lead to misguided recommendations 2.
You all have body autonomy. You all can make whatever decisions you want to make with your body.
--- Samuel Holley
Understanding personal health data and consulting with specialists can help maintain a healthy balance over time.
Health Risks
The pursuit of thinness at all costs can lead to severe long-term health risks. warns against the dangers of chronic underfueling, which has forced many athletes to retire early due to health issues 3. Holley adds that while losing weight might seem beneficial, it isn't always healthy, especially if accompanied by symptoms like poor energy and sleep 4.
If you're chasing being as small as possible at all costs, you're going to cause real problems.
---
Addressing nutrition and mindset with professionals can prevent these risks and promote overall well-being.
Mental Health
Maintaining physical and mental health during intense training is crucial. Holley shares that body changes, like those experienced during pregnancy, highlight the limited control we have over our bodies 5. notes that many start running marathons for weight loss, but this isn't a sustainable strategy 6.
You think you have a lot of control over your body composition, but you don't.
--- Samuel Holley
Focusing on health beyond weight and understanding individual limits can lead to better training outcomes.
Related Episodes


s3/e28 "Why Am I Getting Slower?" with Amanda Brooks & Laura Norris, MS
Answers 383 questions
s1/e08 Running & Weight Loss with Steph Hnatiuk, RD (Steph The Runner's Dietitian)
Answers 383 questions

s1/e02 Running Nutrition with Cortney Berling, MPH, RD
Answers 383 questions
s4/e07 The Half Marathon Training Episode! with Coach Elisabeth
Answers 383 questions

s3/e34 Improving as a Marathoner Over Time with Coach Jessie Gruca
Answers 383 questions

s1/e19 Fundamentals of Nutrition for Athletes with Jen Scott, RD (@marathonmama_rd)
Answers 383 questions

s2/e37 Back to Back Marathons (& other races) with Stevie Lyn Smith, MS, RDN, CSSD, CDN
Answers 383 questions
